Skip to main content

Joe Biden • Donald Trump

Fact Check: Biden on the Stump

We fact-check nine claims made by the Democratic presidential nominee in recent campaign speeches

Joe Biden Campaign
Demetrius Freeman/The Washington Post via Getty Images
Former Vice President and presidential nominee Joe Biden gives remarks at UA Plumbers Local 27 Erie Training Center in Erie, Pennsylvania, on Oct. 10, 2020.

After months of doing mostly virtual events due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden returned to in-person events with small, socially distanced crowds in September. He’s kept up his travel in October.

We reviewed Biden’s speeches on the stump between Oct. 12 and 16. He held six events over three days in swing states: two in Ohio, two in Florida and two more in Michigan. All combined, he spoke for almost two hours and 46 minutes, or less than 30 minutes per speech. His shortest speech (in Detroit) was about 19 minutes, and his longest (in Cincinnati) was more than 34 minutes.

Here, we’ve compiled his false, misleading or exaggerated claims from those speeches.

(We published a similar story looking at statements made by President Donald Trump during his stump speeches over the same period.) 

Social Security

In two of his speeches, Biden misleadingly focused on only part of past comments Trump has made about the payroll tax that funds Social Security, as well as only part of a government analysis of hypothetical legislation eliminating that tax.

“We’ve seen his pledge, quote, ‘to terminate the tax dedicated to financing Social Security,’” Biden said in Toledo, Ohio. “You know what the actuary at the Social Security department said? If it goes through … it will actually bankrupt, bankrupt Social Security by the middle of 2023.”

In an Aug. 24 letter, the Social Security Administration’s chief actuary said eliminating the Social Security payroll tax without providing an alternative source of funding would deplete the trust fund for retirement benefits by 2023, “with no ability to pay” benefits after that year. But that’s not what Trump has proposed, as we’ve written before.

On multiple occasions in August, the president said if he wins reelection he would look at “ending” or “terminating the payroll tax.” However, White House and Trump campaign officials said the president only wants Congress to forgive a four-month Social Security payroll tax holiday for employees that he authorized that month. Congress could transfer money from the government’s general fund to make up the lost tax revenue, Trump said.

Even when Trump said he was “going to terminate the payroll tax,” as he did in an Aug. 12 press conference, he said the money to pay benefits would instead come from general revenues. In the Aug. 24 letter, the chief actuary said a law with that stipulation would leave the Social Security program “essentially unaffected.” 

PolitiFact managing editor Katie Sanders fact checked claims by both President Trump and Joe Biden from last night’s first presidential debate, including misleading statements from Trump about insulin costs and...
Preexisting Conditions

One of Biden’s most frequent claims was that if Trump gets his way, and the Supreme Court strikes down the Affordable Care Act in an upcoming case, protections for more than 100 million people with preexisting health conditions would be jeopardized.

“[I]t’s all about wiping out the Affordable Care Act, which has been an obsession for this president since he became president,” Biden said in Cincinnati. “That’s going to take away preexisting conditions coverage for a hundred-plus million Americans.”

The 100 million figure is an estimate of how many Americans not on Medicare or Medicaid have preexisting conditions. The ACA instituted sweeping protections for those with preexisting conditions, prohibiting insurers in all markets from denying coverage or charging more based on health status. But only those seeking coverage on the individual or nongroup market would immediately be at risk of being denied insurance.

Even without the ACA, employer plans couldn’t deny issuing a policy — and could only decline coverage for some preexisting conditions for a limited period if a new employee had a lapse in coverage.

As of 2018, nearly 20 million people, or about 6% of the U.S. population, got coverage on the individual market, where those without employer or public insurance buy plans.

Health Insurance

Also in Cincinnati, Biden blamed Trump for millions already losing health insurance during the pandemic. “Because of his mishandling the economy and COVID … 10 million people have already lost their employer-based health insurance, 10 million,” Biden said.

As we’ve written, the Urban Institute did estimate that 10.1 million people were expected to lose their employer-based health insurance during the COVID-19 recession. But Biden neglected to mention that study also said that most would regain insurance from another source, leaving 3.5 million uninsured.

Face Masks

In his Southfield, Michigan, speech, while stressing the need to wear face coverings during the pandemic, Biden said of Trump: “It’s estimated by his own folks, if we just wore masks nationally, almost 100,000 lives would be saved in the next few months. His own director of CDC said while we’re waiting for a vaccine, even if we had a vaccine, this [mask] will prevent more deaths between now and the end of January than a vaccine would.”

As we’ve noted before, 100,000-plus preventable deaths was a projection from the University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation — not the Trump administration. On Sept. 3, IHME said increased face mask use in the U.S. could save 122,000 lives between early September and Jan. 1, 2021. As of Oct. 15, IHME said with almost universal face mask use, 74,000 lives could be saved from then until Feb. 1, 2021.

Also, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Robert Redfield did tell senators in congressional testimony in mid-September that face masks currently “are the most important, powerful public health tool we have” against COVID-19.

“I will continue to appeal for all Americans, all individuals in our country, to embrace these face coverings,” Redfield said. “I have said it, if we did it for six, eight, 10, 12 weeks we would bring this pandemic under control. … We have clear scientific evidence they work and they are our best defense.”

As far as comparing face masks and a vaccine, Redfield didn’t definitively say the former would save more lives — although he said masks may offer more protection. “I might even go so far as to say that this face mask is more guaranteed to protect me against COVID than when I take a COVID vaccine,” Redfield told the Senate panel.

He later clarified his remarks on Twitter. “I 100% believe in the importance of vaccines and the importance in particular of a #COVID19 vaccine. A COVID-19 vaccine is the thing that will get Americans back to normal everyday life,” he wrote. “The best defense we currently have against this virus are the important mitigation efforts of wearing a mask, washing your hands, social distancing and being careful about crowds. #COVID19.”

Misquoting McConnell

As he frequently does, Biden misquoted Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s response to Democratic attempts to help cities and states that have lost revenue as a result of the pandemic.

“But you know what Mitch McConnell said recently about helping the states and cities. He said, quote, ‘Let them go bankrupt,’” Biden claimed in his Toledo speech. But, as we’ve written, McConnell said bankruptcy should be a legal option for states facing money woes unrelated to the coronavirus, such as debt due to pension programs.

In an April 22 radio interview, McConnell said: “I would certainly be in favor of allowing states to use the bankruptcy route,” when asked about states with budgetary woes predating the pandemic. The Republican senator made clear in subsequent interviews that he was saying bankruptcy should be “an option” to “fix age-old problems” in states “wholly unrelated” to the coronavirus pandemic. “I wasn’t saying they had to take bankruptcy,” he said in an April 27 Fox News Radio interview. “I think it’s just an option to be looked at, that unfortunately states don’t have that option now, cities do.”

Ivy League Presidents

Biden, who graduated from the University of Delaware and Syracuse Law School, sometimes tells the story that, if elected, he would be the first non-Ivy League president in U.S. history or, as he said more recently, at least the first in 80 or 90 years. But it’s not true.

In Toledo, Biden said he has a “little bit of a chip on my shoulder about guys like him,” referring to Trump, who graduated from the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Finance. “I read some stories after I got the nomination that quote, ‘If Biden gets elected, he’ll be the first non-Ivy League school graduate to get elected in … 80 or 90 years,’” Biden said. “But folks, since when can someone who went to a state university not be qualified to be president?”

It’s true that the last five presidents earned degrees from Ivy League schools. But Ronald Reagan went to Eureka College. Jimmy Carter graduated from the United States Naval Academy. Richard Nixon graduated from Whittier College and Duke University Law School. If Biden would win, he would be the first non-Ivy League president in 32 years.

Auto Bailout

At one of his two Michigan events, Biden recalled how, “over the objections of many, we stepped in and rescued the automobile industry,” referring to himself and former President Barack Obama.

The Obama administration can claim credit for helping to resuscitate the auto industry after the 2008 economic crisis. However, as we’ve explained, the rescue effort began on Dec. 19, 2008, when then-President George W. Bush announced his administration would provide General Motors and Chrysler with $13.4 billion in loans under the Troubled Asset Relief Program, plus an additional $4 billion to GM after Congress approved releasing the second half of TARP funds. As part of the deal, the automakers were required to come up with a long-term viability plan by March 31, 2009.

The companies’ viability plans were ultimately rejected on March 30, 2009, by Obama, who later announced an agreement on a restructuring plan for Chrysler and GM on April 30 and June 1, respectively. As a result, the automakers filed for bankruptcy, restructured their companies and got more federal assistance. In total, the Treasury Department invested about $80 billion in the auto industry and ended up getting back all but $9.3 billion of that amount.

Beau Biden

In nearly all of his stump speeches, Biden mentioned his late son, Beau Biden, who died of brain cancer in 2015. But in his remarks in Pembroke Pines, Florida, Biden falsely suggested that Beau was the only “foreigner” to have his own monument and highway in Kosovo. 

“My son volunteered to go to Iraq for a year,” Biden said of Beau, who served in the Delaware Army National Guard. “Before that, he had been in Kosovo for eight months. Best of my knowledge, the only foreigner who has a war monument and a major highway in that country named after him for his contribution to helping them set up their criminal justice system.”

In 2016, the Kosovo government did unveil a statue dedicated to Beau, “who worked in Kosovo after the 1998-99 war ended, helping train local prosecutors and judges for the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe,” according to Reuters. The country also renamed a highway leading to an American military base after him as well. But he’s not the only American to receive such an honor.

As Time magazine wrote: “The ethnically Albanian and predominantly Muslim statelet at the southern-most tip of what was once Yugoslavia is perhaps the most pro-American country in the world. Its capital, Pristina, has boulevards named for presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush (spelled Xhorxh Bush) and a street named for Bob Dole. It also features an 11-foot tall statue of Clinton.” The statue of Clinton was revealed in 2009.

Reuters said: “Clinton, as leader of the NATO alliance, is seen as the man who decided to bomb Serbia to force the late strongman Slobodan Milosevic to withdraw his forces from Kosovo, effectively handing victory to the Kosovo Liberation Army.”

Editor’s Note: Please consider a donation to FactCheck.org. We do not accept advertising. We rely on grants and individual donations from people like you. Credit card donations may be made through our “Donate” page. If you prefer to give by check, send to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, 202 S. 36th St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.

read://https_www.nbcchicago.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nbcchicago.com%2Fnews%2Fnational-international%2Ffact-check-biden-on-the-stump%2F2357787%2F

Comments

Latest Post

Recent Posts Widget

Popular posts from this blog

Last month, Britney Spears finally married Sam Asghari in an intimate ceremony at their Thousand Oaks home after almost six years together.

  Last month, Britney Spears finally married Sam Asghari in  an intimate ceremony  at their Thousand Oaks home after almost six years together. Instagram: @britneyspears The pair first met in October 2016, when Sam was cast as Britney’s love interest in the music video for her single “Slumber Party,” which was filmed in a Beverly Hills mansion. Colin Tilley ADVERTISEMENT Britney made their relationship Instagram official in January the following year, when she shared a photo of herself having dinner with Sam on New Year’s Day. Instagram: @https://www.instagram.com/britneyspears/?hl=en And Sam has previously shed some light on his and Britney’s first meeting and how their romance came to be, admitting to  Men’s Health  in July 2018 that he “had butterflies” before he met the pop star. Colin Tilley “She said, ‘Hi, I’m Britney,’ and I said, ‘I’m sorry, what’s your name again?’” he said at the time. “I tried to be funny. I don’t think anybody got it.” Vivien Killile...
The majestic and mysterious nature with the clear blue water flowing in the middle of the thousand has created a beautiful scene at Toc Tien waterfall in Quang Binh.  About Toc Tien waterfall in Quang Binh  Quang Binh Toc Tien Waterfall is not as high as the 9-story waterfall, but it is wider and wider. The water here is clear, flowing strongly into the wide lake below. After a long way to move here, many tourists will surely be very refreshed when they lightly touch the water with their bare feet. Surrounded by luxuriant trees with a wide canopy radiating shade in the middle of the lake. (Photo: Nhan Dan Newspaper) On the way to the waterfall, you will have to pass through a dense bamboo forest with a scene like a fairy tale movie. Big bamboo trees, almost as tall as an adult's wrist, grow towering, making the whole journey very comfortable and pleasant.  Toc Tien Waterfall in Quang Binh is located near Dong Chau forest (nature reserve). There are still many plant species ...

Cowboys hit $232 million jackpot

  U.S.A- Unharmed and wasteful, Neal Wanless used part of the winnings to build the 50,000-a-century farm, which is now valued at more than $41 million. In 2009, Neal Wanless was a young cowboy who lived on a farm in Mission, South Dakota. About 48% of the region's population is under difficulties. The Wanless family is no exception. After the 2008 financial crisis, they barely lived enough. They were late to pay taxes, their homes were revoked by the bank, forcing Wanless's parents and brother to move to a small tent. Father Wanless had to sell more scrap metal for a living. Wanless himself continued to work and lived on the family's 230-angst (93 hectares) farm. "We really struggled," Wanless confides. 34-year-old Neal Wanless is loyal to his dream of farming despite winning the jackpot. Photo:  WSJ. One day Wanless went to pour gasoline, he conveniently bought a ticket of $ 15. He never expected any luck, but he couldn't have expected the ticket to win the ...
The nearly 200-year-old persimmon tree in Hoa Lu suddenly became famous, which many people likened to a scene in a Korean historical movie. Ninh Binh is a land with many famous tourist attractions such as Bai Dinh pagoda, Trang An, Tam Coc, Bich Dong, Mua cave... Recently, the travel-loving community on social networks has been buzzing with check coordinates. new print. It is an ancient persimmon tree in the campus of a household in Khe Ha hamlet, Ninh Xuan commune, Hoa Lu district. This brand new place on the tourist map is only about 700 meters from Mua Cave, attracting many tourists to Ninh Binh in the past 2 weeks. According to the share of the head of the household, Mrs. Xiem, 73 years old, the persimmon tree is about 180-190 years old. It is estimated that the tree has been there for 4 generations. Persimmon trees begin to bear green fruit from March to March. By about September, the fruit begins to turn yellow and when ripe it is as red as a tomato. Mrs. Siam said that the o...
The upcoming Lunar New Year holiday 2021 is coming, in addition to being reunited with family, this is also an opportunity for everyone to plan a trip to welcome spring and enjoy the warm atmosphere at the beginning of the year. Are you planning a trip for Tet 2021? And you wonder about the next step? Vinlove will suggest attractive tourist destinations that promise to bring you the most complete spring trip. Moc Chau Moc Chau is a land with a strange attraction, always attracted by its wild, mysterious and profound beauty at any time of the year. Pure plum blossom, ban flower, brilliant peach blossom, graceful white canola flower season. However, that country is probably the most beautiful in spring with the pink color of peach blossom, the pure white color of apricot blossom, plum blossom... The beauty of the Northwest spring makes people's hearts flutter and urges the feet. love to explore. Xuan Moc Chau has a cool climate, gentle sunshine spreads throughout the village, m...

What to eat with US$4.3 in downtown Hanoi - VinLove

What to eat with US$4.3 in downtown Hanoi - VinLove : Below is a list of quality restaurants offering food for less than VND100,000 (US$ 4.3) per person in the busiest central districts of the capital city of

The Voice • Blake Shelton • Gwen Stefani • Kelly Clarkson • Nbc

'The Voice': Blake Shelton and Gwen Stefani Face Off Over a Singer in Season 19 Premiere Blake Shelton   and   Gwen Stefani   are happy to be back together on the new season of  The Voice   -- but they're not pulling any punches with each other! The couple wasted no time on Monday's season 19 premiere before they were facing off over a singer. Payge Turner, a 27-year-old crooner from Trinidad and Tobago, got an early chair turn from Blake as she covered The Weeknd's "Call Out My Name," but then Gwen hit her button just before the end of the song. "Why are you doing this to me?!" Blake exclaimed, as John Legend warned the hopeful singer, "You're about to break up America's couple!" Blake did his best to make a case for his team -- pointing out the fact that he turned much earlier than his ladylove -- but ultimately, Payge went for the glitz, girl power and cross-genre experience that Team Gwen had to offer. "I'm always l...

Step-By-Step Guide To Planning An Awesome Trip To Vietnam | How to Plan a Vietnam Travel

  A  comprehensive guide to everything you need to know when  planning a trip  to  Vietnam Where should travel in Vietnam in August? Suggested destinations for the exciting end of summer August 4, 2021   vinlove   0 August is the time when it is a bit floating, late summer and early autumn it is not too hot nor cold, is the most  […] 17 most beautiful waterfalls in Vietnam you cannot ignore August 3, 2021   vinlove   0 Explore all parts of the country from the North to the South, from the majestic unspoiled Northwest mountains to the thousands of Central Highlands to  […] 8 most beautiful forests in Vietnam August 3, 2021   vinlove   0 The golden forest, the silver sea, the beauty of the forests always makes us feel cool and comfortable. On this dear S-shaped strip of land, there  […] Top 13 most dangerous and conquering passes in Vietnam August 2, 2021   vinlove   0 Although considered as dangerous roa...

Lốc xoáy lửa bên trong bong bóng

EXPLORE VIETNAM NEW POSTS 23-01-2023

  NEW POSTS Tay Do teacher shows off her talent to “make up” for Tet fruits, everyone will love them when they see them January 23, 2023   0 The guy crocheted wool into all kinds of flowers, selling a few million dongs a pot on the Tet holiday January 23, 2023   0 Strangely, the sacred stone was built by the whole village to pray for good luck in Ha Tinh January 23, 2023   0 Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City are peaceful on the morning of the first day of Tet January 22, 2023   0 Peaceful Hoi An near Tet January 22, 2023   0 Coffee shops open during Tet in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City January 22, 2023   0 Taste of the Northern New Year in winter meat January 22, 2023   0 Two days of cycling more than 240 km back home to celebrate Tet January 22, 2023   0 Can Tho giants spend billions to build an “ecological area” of more than 10,000 square meters next to the mansion for people to enjoy Tet completely free of charge January 22, 2023   0 The hottes...